It’s not at all obvious why this inequitable FAA policy exists. As it’s based on a regulation you could submit a petition for exemption.
Order 8900.1, vol 5, ch 2, sec 14 (link)
Para 5–594 OBTAINING A U.S. PILOT CERTIFICATE.
…
C. Foreign Pilot License.
…
4) … However, if a person other than a holder of a Student Pilot Certificate already holds a standard U.S. pilot certificate, that person may not apply for a U.S. pilot certificate on the basis of a foreign pilot license (refer to § 61.75(b)(3)), unless they voluntarily surrender their U.S. pilot certificate.
What would be the process to surrender one’s standalone FAA certificate?
I’m assuming the advantage of flying on a 61.75 (‘Piggyback’) as against a ‘Stand Alone’ is that one would not need a separate FAA Medical to exercise IR privileges?
What are the other advantages/disadvantages of such a move?
One consistent advantage of an FAA Stand Alone, is that I have never been questioned about it; and it has even been allowed as a Passport substitute.
The process for voluntarily surrendering a US certificate or rating is set out in FAA Order 8900.1, vol 5, ch 2, sec 5, para 5–320.
Peter_G, the main disadvantage is that the relevant foreign rating(s) must be valid. This can be inferred from an explicit statement in 8900.1, vol 5, ch 2, sec 23 which deals with US certificates/ratings issued in pursuance of a bilateral agreement. Specifically, para 5-2-23-7 (definitions), item T:
T. Valid Pilot License or Pilot Certificate. With respect to an FAA pilot certificate or an EU Part-FCL pilot license, validity means that the certificate or license is not surrendered, suspended, or revoked. For an EU Part-FCL rating, it also means that a rating’s validity period stated on the pilot license has not expired.
In other words, it seems the Administration will interpret an expired Part-FCL rating as a limitation for the purpose of 14 CFR 61.75(e)(3).