Menu Sign In Contact FAQ
EuroGA Banner
Welcome to our forums

Electric / hybrid aircraft propulsion (NOT cars)

Why on earth would one block a video from certain countries?

Finally, for the first time in years, I see an electric plane at Shoreham:

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom
Maoraigh
EGPE, United Kingdom

The Pipistrel in my post above is currently stuck there, because the charger packed up and had to be taken away for repair.

The plane, G-KDKD, has been crashed in 2023. But the interesting thing is that it is (or was) owned by the very outfit which is paying airfields to install the chargers!

I wonder how many of these are owned by real people? It is understandable that this is “for show” since the range of these is barely to the next airfield with a charger, so who would buy one for normal flying?

The Loganair mission profile probably works for the short inter-island hops.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

Peter wrote:

I wonder how many of these are owned by real people? It is understandable that this is “for show” since the range of these is barely to the next airfield with a charger, so who would buy one for normal flying?

I doubt that any are, maybe one or two idealists who wish to make a statement. As travel planes they are useless, what they are ok for is to do basic circuit training with them. So I’d think most of them are flight schools who wish to appease the local nimby crowd by stating how clean they operate. Nothing wrong with that, apart that it won’t have the effect on the Nimby’s as nothing will ever appease that kind of folks.

LSZH(work) LSZF (GA base), Switzerland

The charger at EGKA packed up (probably the spiders got inside smiley) so the guy who runs that whole show (the airport paid nothing for this) put in this new one

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

What’s their business model? Can’t be selling electricity to visiting aircraft since they would have run out of money after the first few months with no one ever using these chargers.

EDQH, Germany

Given the planes have barely enough range to fly to the nearest other airport with a charger, I have absolutely no idea what the business model might be. If these planes existed in numbers, charger utilisation would be 100% smiley

The planes I’ve seen there (1 or maybe 2?) are owned by the charger installer, as a promotion I guess. It seems basically a dead proposition.

We’ve done this in this thread many times. It looks like electric GA planes are viable for circuit training and that’s it.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

Another variation on the hybrid theme, with Deltahawk also somehow involved.

All very nebulous. Quite a lot of cited orders for something that doesn‘t seem to exist other than on paper.

Last Edited by chflyer at 03 Aug 16:16
LSZK, Switzerland

Anyone who has spent any time in or around the commercial aspects of any startup-type business will tell you that what they declare as ‘orders’ usually involves a particularly interesting interpretation of the term.

Basically anyone who so much as smiled at the description of the intended product is counted as an ‘order’.

EGLM & EGTN

One has to consider the pace of battery development though. With so much money flowing into electric cars I imagine that battery development will continue full speed ahead, and the capacity has historically gone up exponentially over time.

If this problem could be solved, assuming it will be, electric airplanes have great advantages over ICE. Firstly electric engines are super simple so not as much can go wrong and maintenance is greatly simplified. Secondly, since they don’t need air they produce constant power regardless of altitude making them potentially very fast touring machines if you climb high enough.

It all comes down to batteries, whether they can be small enough, reliable enough, and resistant to a range of temperatures.

EGKB, United Kingdom
Sign in to add your message

Back to Top