Menu Sign In Contact FAQ
EuroGA Banner
Welcome to our forums

UK CAA looking to mandate ADS-B OUT

You want this but it is illegal. Such a product could be sold only into the Exp market.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

I’m unsure about the certified TAS, but since they also emit ADS-B, Powerflarm can display all this if I understand this correctly. Not sure if colision warnings work by anything but proximity (FLARM takes speed and direction into account to generate a warning, that’s why it works in a glider gaggle) but that’s totally enough for GA or drones.

Edit: now I understand, your issue is about the legalese jungle of certification and what would happen if a drone caused a crash because it relied on SIL 0 data. A valid concern, but since ADS-B can already be fed by SIL 0, there is little that can be improved here without demanding not only an ADSB out but also a certain signal integrity level along with it.

Last Edited by Inkognito at 15 Sep 08:39
EDAY, Germany

FLARM would work well with drones, that is true, and it would allow most GA planes to see them. However, it is not a solution for airliners or mil planes. There have been ideas to incorporate FLARM also for airliners and larger GA, but so far it has come to nothing. In the end, the solution has to be one supported by ICAO and with it FAA and EASA. Nothing else will finally do the job.

I reckon that only ADS-B is the real solution here and it should sooner or later replace all other such devices, to have ONE standard for everyone.

The other factor of course is that with the increasing use of drones for military and secret service operations as well as in actual warfare, is it still reasonable to allow civil drones at all. While they are useful for certain applications, certainly there is no case for recreational drones in times of war. Professionally used drones are usually larger and more sophisticated and could easily carry some sort of ADS-B beacon.

LSZH(work) LSZF (GA base), Switzerland

FLARM would work well with drones, that is true, and it would allow most GA planes to see them

The vast majority of GA planes do not have FLARM.

Professionally used drones are usually larger and more sophisticated and could easily carry some sort of ADS-B beacon.

Definitely.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

EASA is going for ADS-L as a unified E-conspicuity solution.

ESKC (Uppsala/Sundbro), Sweden

Peter wrote:

The vast majority of GA planes do not have FLARM.

A flarm solution can cost as less as 50USD…
https://lilygo.cc/products/t-echo-softrf-firmware?variant=52153196052661

EBZH, Belgium

Airborne_Again wrote:

EASA is going for ADS-L as a unified E-conspicuity solution.

I have a device transmitting ADS-L. But the downside is that it creates a two user system. ADS-B and ADS-L. Those with one, can’t necessarily see the other (though I think in practice most ADS-L systems will also pick up ADS-B as it’s so easy to do). ADS-B systems are less likely to pick up ADS-L though.

EIKH Kilrush, Ireland

Isn’t a typical (certified or not) ADS-B IN system going to pick up ADS-L but at a closer range only?

IOW, it’s like the SkyEcho 2 which (assuming the crappy GPS in it is working at all) is visible from a few miles away. Uavionix UK more or less told me the range is only about that. I bet they are more than happy with this CAA proposal, having employed some ex CAA guys smiley

A flarm solution can cost as less as 50USD…

Sure but that does not integrate with any display in the typical GA aircraft. We did FLARM + ADS-B IN (+TAS in more advanced aircraft) integration / data merging before and it is doable, with doubtful legality in certified aircraft, and perhaps not with any current product. And in the UK, Annex 1 needs LAA approval for mods…

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

Peter wrote:

Isn’t a typical (certified or not) ADS-B IN system going to pick up ADS-L but at a closer range only?

No. ADS-L operate on a different frequency.

EIKH Kilrush, Ireland

Peter wrote:

Sure but that does not integrate with any display in the typical GA aircraft. We did FLARM + ADS-B IN (+TAS in more advanced aircraft) integration / data merging before and it is doable, with doubtful legality in certified aircraft, and perhaps not with any current product.
Gliders are certified aircraft and CS-STAN is your friend, you can install Flarm easily. I understand the UK kept CS-Stan within their own regulations.
And a modern Powerflarm can display Flarm, Fanet+, ADS-B, (limited) Mode S targets, and also ADS-L.
EDAY, Germany
Sign in to add your message

Back to Top