Menu Sign In Contact FAQ
EuroGA Banner
Welcome to our forums

100UL (merged thread)

Pardon my ignorance, still wondering why I should buy a STC doc? If the fuel is fine for the engine/plane – what is the point ?
(UL91 is/was fine, usable with CS-STAN – just hardly available anywhere)
Will the fuel station not fill my tank w/o it or what is their leverage ?

...
EDM_, Germany

If somebody gets an STC for something, they are entitled to charge for its use.

If I got an STC on air, I could charge you for breathing smiley That actually isn’t totally silly because a lot of aviation STCs cover stuff which involves prior art so the STC is (or should be) worthless. STCs are enforced at the point of installation so if the installer refuses, you are screwed. A 100UL STC is “supposed to be” enforced at the pump and your guess is as good as mine whether the “pump man” is going to bother.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

ch.ess wrote:

UL91 is/was fine […] – just hardly available anywhere

Very much country dependent.

ESKC (Uppsala/Sundbro), Sweden

I think their own text says a lot about why they sell an STC:

It’s not about enforcement.

ESMK, Sweden

If you fly your aircraft outside of the limits of the type certificate including supplements, your TC is not ‘in full force and effect’, the aircraft isn’t legally airworthy and therefore your insurance is likely invalid. Insurance is the greatest motivator for buying an STC for any modification. The retailer of any fuel is not going to care if the TC of your plane doesn’t include a given fuel because he’s selling the fuel to you, not to the plane. The legality of what you do with the fuel is your business, not his, and the legality isn’t obvious anyway.

The only exception I could imagine to the above is if the franchise agreement to sell the fuel requires the retailer to verify the STC as a commercial issue. I don’t think many retailers would sign up for that if it were the case, not least because the STC record is not legally required to be with the plane.

Last Edited by Silvaire at 27 Jul 17:49

I think their own text says a lot about why they sell an STC:

Sure; they want to make money. “We” are also entitled to hold a view that they make money on the fuel smiley If I fill up my VW at a pump then why don’t I need to buy an STC?

IMHO this STC sale is just a cynical ploy at carving up the market. If you land at airport X which sells 100UL Brand A, and 100UL Brand B, and you bought the STC for A but not bought the STC for B, then you cannot buy B. Not even if your plane is stuck there (because they have run out of A) and you are paying €100/day for parking. That plane cannot be moved except on the back of a pick up truck. A lovely position to be in.

It is like the TOTAL 91UL business some years ago, where they were trying to get airports to sell their 91UL (and hopefully stop selling 100LL) and they were even giving away 91UL bowsers. They “forgot” that loads of planes cannot burn 91UL – even in Europe! They failed…

People usually vote with their feet, and that means both pilots and airport managers who make roughly €0.30 per litre. If nobody buys the fuel, they make €0.00 per litre, and they can definitely tell the difference between say 200L x 0.30 and 0 × 0.00.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom



Guernsey (EGJB), United Kingdom

It would be great if someone posted a summary of this 1hr video.

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom

https://www.faa.gov/unleaded/Transition_Plan_to_UL_Avgas_20260728_V1.pdf

On Page 13-
…The primary challenge is that the unleaded fuels contain no lead and therefore cannot meet Table 1 properties of ASTM D910 specification for 100LL. As stated in the UAT ARC Final Report, “There has been extensive testing to find a fuel that meets all of
the current ASTM D910 leaded aviation gasoline specification properties for 100LL, satisfies the safety and performance requirements of engines and aircraft, is compatible with the existing infrastructure, and poses no additional compositional issues. Thus, the fuel would have been considered a drop-in fuel, and if such a fuel had been available, it is likely the industry would have transitioned to this fuel once it became available to the General Aviation market.” The FAA has determined that a drop-in replacement for 100LL is not feasible.

From BT.

https://www.beechtalk.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=248243&hilit=ASTM&start=0

GAMI claim in the video their fuel G100UL is the closest to commercial replacement, but will require an STC. Also that the TEL plant may close in 2028.

I am concerned, and the second hand GA market for airplanes that have to use 100LL is being impacted. OTOH Cirrus is still producing 600-700 100UL airplanes p.a. so either informed industry participants are relaxed, or, as the video suggests, we should be concerned.

Last Edited by RobertL18C at 09 Aug 11:07
Guernsey (EGJB), United Kingdom

I think Beechtalk is entirely behind a login… one way to defeat the botnet etc attacks which have caused so much trouble here on EuroGA!

But whatever the situation with 100 UL is, the stories about TEL ending are all FALSE. There is no reason, technical or financial, for mfg of TEL to end, and there are multiple sources.

Cirrus evidently hold the view that 100LL will remain available in the markets relevant to them, which is probably 90% in the US. If Europe bans 100LL without a replacement, it will merely shoot itself in the foot and damage the GA scene even more than it is already damaged.

Why is G Braly saying an STC will be needed? Is it some legalistic reason, or is there a real performance difference?

Administrator
Shoreham EGKA, United Kingdom
Sign in to add your message

Back to Top