What precedent is there for fleet grounding on the basis that it is difficult for students to fly?
More like something came off on the last crash, suggesting a design problem.
Or a manufacturing issue. In the Elixir thread, someone described a long delay due to cellophane being present between the supposedly glued together layers…
Probably unrelated, the September Info-Pilote magazine had an article on runway excursions. 3 of the 10 incidents studied were Elixir Aircraft. The key points have mostly been covered in this thread, but a quick summary:
The general trend is a) the aircraft being landed too fast and b) the engine mounts not standing up to ‘normal’ heavy landings.
A major factor is the published approach speeds: the POH is 1.3VS at MTOM, which becomes 1.48VS at lower weight. Some aeroclub checklists round this up to 1.55VS. The accident flights were 1.6 to 1.72VS.
With a large delta between cruise and landing speeds, and a low-drag airframe, the transition from enroute to approach is more difficult, particularly for students. The controls are more responsive and therefore less forgiving, especially in conjunction with non-standard circuits (for e.g. noise abatement).
The writer says there’s an unprecedented situation where the Robin/Cessna/Piper techniques taught at a national level and propagated via instructors and clubs are now no longer appropriate.
Loads of planes are much easier to break than a C152, and I would bet that is true for 100% of ULs, but that is not a likely reason for grounding the fleet.
So one of the flaps departed the aircraft on approach to a tough and go during a low level circuit.
It’s not known why it departed yet.
After completing two laps of the runway at the Rochefort aerodrome, one of the pilots announced himself for a low-level circuit. During the last turn for runway 12, the left flap detached from the aircraft. The pilot lost control of the aircraft. The aircraft’s reserve parachute is activated at low height. The plane collided with the ground.
So one of the flaps departed the aircraft on approach to a tough and go during a low level circuit.
It’s not known why it departed yet.
That on the other hand is as good a reason as any to ground the aircraft until it is known why.
Peter wrote:
I would bet that is true for 100% of ULs
There’s one or two microlights (such as C42 or Skyranger) which are extremely simple in design and construction and survive just fine in a flying school environment, better so than a 152. But they are rag and tube designs, not remotely glamorous. Not a composite relatively high performance machine like an Elixir
It’s 2026 and people die on a factory built, brand new certified aircraft due to structural failure.
Something must have gone terribly wrong. I m asking myself when was the last time that a flight control surface departed a certified aircraft during normal approach to landing?