Menu Sign In Contact FAQ
Banner
Welcome to Euro GA. This website is the home of interesting, informed and intelligent discussion about General Aviation in Europe. We hope you'll enjoy it and find it useful. Please do get involved by posting on our forums and take a look at our articles. If you'd like to publish any  yourself then please get in touch.  

New! EuroGA Classifieds. Buy or sell everything aviation related.


What We're Talking About On EuroGA >>

Airprox caught on video...what is the point of reporting it?

Cit mus flt18 hires Howard graff 000avatar09 Images Tb20 9 G ahau sml Pilot 02 Image Serenity 500px Phoenixf Om ipe Ich3 Image Hbdwcavtar Img 0339

I flew in to a UK airfield on Saturday…calling up five minutes or so out. An air/ground Radio service. We passed the standard messages and then there was silence on the radio – no other traffic. As I approached the overhead I called again and then a few seconds later suddenly a Robin with angled wings flew massively fast towards me from my one o’clock. (He then passed on my right – close, but not massively close, but at the same height) The closing speed was incredible. (I was flying at about 130 knots, and I guess the other plane was too.) I have the recordings and he had not spoken to the ground station and was happily flying through their ATZ without speaking to them..or announcing his presence to me or others in the circuit. (In fact it was just me in the circuit.) The other plane, having heard me call up on a standard overhead join announced as being from the south, would have known that if he continued on his route north to south through the ATZ he’d be approaching me head-on.

I called “traffic!” on the radio for no reason I can think of – just panic I think. The look on my face in the video and the subsequent swearing says it all. The other plane replied “We saw you coming” without ending the message with his call sign. (All caught on my video) But I don’t believe him for one second because seeing him approach and pass me on the video at say 250kts, it’s clear to me that he was not visible to me until about 2 seconds away and the same must be true of my plane to him – invisible. (5 seconds away at 250 kts is 700 yards away by my calculation. It’s not very easy to recognise a stationary plane head on at 700 yards on the ground. Something 700 yards away moving really quickly towards you, against a white cloud background, is almost completely invisible)

I phoned the airfield today. The CFI told me that their fleet doesn’t include any angled wings Robins (just some of the older Robins with straight metal wings). He was completely unimpressed by the other chap’s airmanship flying through their ATZ unannounced.

So, what happens if I report this to the Airprox Board? They’ll investigate. Speak to the other pilot if they can trace him (probably can) but then they do nothing. So what is the point? Anyone have a view?

Perhaps I should just make a few bob on YouTube by posting the video and waiting for the first thousand views…

(BTW, sadly my PowerFlarm can be seen issuing an alarm in the video, but only about half a second before the closest approach. The approach speed is simply too fast for the machine to recognise the threat until too late. This because the other plane had no ADS-B Out, or Flarm, just a transponder that doesn’t of course give a direction signal to the PowerFlarm collision avoidance device.)

Two different AI presentations - confusing?

G ahau sml Hbdwcavtar Dscn1198 Cit mus flt18 hires Avatar Phoenixf Tb20 9 Serenity 500px

Sadly I can’t find a picture showing a bank angle, but these two presentations appear the opposite of each other when turning.

Today I flew a NP IAP by hand, in the dark, to see how well it works just on the lower one. It does take quite a while to get used to it.

Ich3
OK understand, you meant LFLS specifically... Yes, there is a handful of such places in France. Mende is another one. I think it has to do with no H24 airport being sufficiently close by to be abl...
Img 0339
Three days sounds good, probably take me three days to fly back.
Avatar
David Clark H10-13X AH100 headset https://www.amazon.co.uk/General-Aviation-Headset-Premium-Reduction/dp/B01J79PUL8/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1478183636&sr=8-4&keywords=flight+headset GPS...
Img 7354
Nice. Welcome to my home turf. We would have run into each other at the Bistro at EDLE possibly, as I was planning a short flight to Hamm-Lippewiesen to walk from their airfield to the Christmas ma...
Hbdwcavtar
Hello Jason I originally thought so too, particularly as the ATCO does indeed give him a clearance how to proceed after the GA. The message from the plane to the tower to which she replies with tha...
Cit mus flt18 hires
Maybe it is me but I can't see another aircraft in that video. He was departing through the overhead, was transponding and you were arriving through and doing the same. He says he saw you, why do y...
Pilot
I suffered heavily from the leans during incompleted IFR training several years ago. I learned to fly through it. I'm surprised to hear some people never feel it. I think that's alarming because...
Pilot
I cant see an option like that on my PocketFms.
Tb20 9
I have just heard from a Greek local that this ex-military pilot, and an FI, did a touch and go in the car park mentioned above, and was unable to avoid the terrain afterwards, possibly due to a de...
Tb20 9
That validates at FL090. If you tried to file below that, it may validate but London Control will chuck it out as soon as IFPS sends it to them, so when you call the departure tower they will ...
Hammer outline
In that case Oslo (Torp) and Paris (Beauvais) must be good candidates too!